Sources & credits · 資料來源與引用

Standing on Giants: Every Mathematician Behind the Riemann Hypothesis Proof

Every public source, dataset, licence and portrait credit used in the video, with an honest status for each link. Compiled 2026-11-21. 以下為影片使用的所有公開來源、資料庫與頭貼授權;每個連結都標示核對狀態。

48mathematicians in the video
38real portraits with a Commons source (21 public domain, 17 CC / GFDL / attribution)
10initials badges (no free portrait found)
72URLs checked; all reachable except 2 that block bots

Read first · 先看這裡

The proof is not independently verified yet. It was announced on 2026-11-20; at the time of writing the Comparator checker had not been run on it (see the repository status). Nothing here is a verification. 證明於 2026-11-20 公布,尚未獨立驗證。

Status labels. Reachable = the URL was requested on 2026-11-21 and answered. Reachable, entry not checked Blocked to bots = reachable, but the content could not be confirmed automatically. Local file, not public = not a public link. Not recorded = information missing.

Numbers quoted in the video (e.g. 1,246,092 theorem declarations, 113 named theorems, 65 subfields) come from the creator’s own analysis reports (section 5) and were not recomputed for this page.

1Lean submission & public export · 一手資料

The proof itself, its verification setup and the public export of the Lean data.

ItemSourceUsed forStatus
Original submission note (Alpöge & Claude)alpo.ge/remark.pdfExplains the core ideas: Stepanov multiplicity method, the √X chain of theta lifts, Behrend-type constructions.
原作者投稿說明;PDF 已確認可開啟(約 245 KB)。
Reachable
Verification repository (Comparator setup)github.com/Deicyde/riemann-hypothesis/blob/a172c464fd4bcfc4f53e394d…Lean sources of the formalization, static-scan status and the Comparator configuration. Cited at commit a172c464.
GitHub 現在把這個倉庫轉到 leanprover-community/riemann-hypothesis(標題:Independent Comparator setup for the Lean formalization of the Riemann Hypothesis)。
Reachable (redirects)
Public Lean export (MIT)math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/Hosts solution.export (lean4export NDJSON 3.1.0) used to count theorem declarations reachable from riemannHypothesis.
頁面標題:RH Lean proof: verification files。
Reachable
Independent proof guide (16-layer main line)nasqret.github.io/riemann-rev/guide/proof-guide.pdfThird-party guide giving the node/edge picture of the proof and the deepest call chain.
獨立導讀 PDF。
Reachable
Guide graph data (model.json)github.com/nasqret/riemann-rev/blob/d53b3804bd013df4cf9af3b40877281…Machine-readable graph behind the guide, pinned to commit d53b3804.Reachable
Lean verification & export toolsgithub.com/leanprover/comparator
github.com/leanprover/lean4export
github.com/leanprover/lean4export/blob/master/format_ndjson.md
Comparator (independent checker) and lean4export, plus the NDJSON format specification.Reachable

2Classification standards · 分類標準

Used as the denominator when the video compares the proof with “all of mathematics”.

ItemSourceUsed forStatus
MSC 2020 (Mathematics Subject Classification)zbmath.org/static/msc2020.pdfTop-level classification of mathematics; the denominator for “how much of mathematics” comparisons.
本機另存:work/rh-knowledge-audit/msc2020.pdf。
Reachable
ICM 2026 structure committee report—The 2023 committee report that defines the ICM 2026 sections.
貼文只給本機檔案(work/rh-knowledge-audit/icm2026.pdf / .txt),沒有公開網址 — 若要在影片說明欄引用,需要補上官方連結。
Local file, not public
The Princeton Companion to Mathematicspress.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691118802/the-princeton-companion-to…
assets.press.princeton.edu/releases/gowers/gowers_preface.pdf
Gowers (ed.): reference for the main lines of contemporary mathematics; preface PDF linked.
出版社頁面對自動檢查回 403;編者前言 PDF 可正常開啟。
Blocked to bots

3Dependency graphs & theorem catalogues · 定理依賴圖與名錄

Where the “which named theorems does the proof reach” counts and cross-checks come from.

ItemSourceUsed forStatus
1000+ theorems catalogue1000-plus.github.io/all
1000-plus.github.io/about/
github.com/1000-plus/1000-plus.github.io/tree/8e04b97dd24adc6e931be…
List of named theorems used to count which famous theorems the proof reaches (snapshot pinned to commit 8e04b97d).
貼文稱命中 113 條;這個數字未由本頁重算。
Reachable, entry not checked
Trough Mathlib dependency graphtrough.jackmccarthy.org/roadmap/mathlib/index.html
github.com/Deicyde/trough/blob/99a78c568cd248a914fd7ea9591f41adee44…
“Proof depends on” edges between Mathlib theorems (concept-deps.json, pinned to commit 99a78c56).Reachable
Mathlib overview (subfields)github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/0df444a360eaa60ab8c11…
github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/tree/0df444a360eaa60ab8c11…
docs/overview.yaml of the same Mathlib version as the submission; groups and subfields of the library.Reachable
The Stacks Projectstacks.math.columbia.edu/statistics
stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0E9C
Reference scale for a permanently-tagged dependency graph in algebraic geometry; tag 0E9C as the example.
標籤 0E9C 頁面標題已確認:Theorem 109.25.3 (0E9C)。
Reachable
TheoremGraph (arXiv:2606.25363)arxiv.org/abs/2606.25363Comparison point: theorem-level dependency extraction.
標題已確認:TheoremGraph: Bridging Formal and Informal Mathematics。
Reachable
Imperial FLT blueprintgithub.com/ImperialCollegeLondon/FLT/blob/main/blueprint-verso/FLTB…Comparison point: Lean blueprint for Fermat's Last Theorem.
指向 main 分支(不是固定版本),內容可能隨時間改變。
Reachable

4Eight key theorems · 8 條關鍵定理

For each theorem: the entry in the 1000+ catalogue and, where the creator recorded one, the original paper.

ItemSourceUsed forStatus
Linnik's least-prime theorem1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q2703389
arxiv.org/abs/0906.2749
Entry in the 1000+ list and the paper “On Linnik's constant”.
arXiv 標題已確認;1000+ 條目頁為 JS 頁面。
Reachable, entry not checked
Ferrero–Washington theorem1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q5445311
annals.math.princeton.edu/1979/190-2/p05
Entry and the original paper (Annals of Math., 1979).
Annals 頁面標題已確認:The Iwasawa μ_p vanishes for abelian number fields。
Reachable, entry not checked
Hironaka: resolution of singularities (char. 0)1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q10942247
jstor.org/stable/1970486
Entry and the JSTOR record of the paper.
JSTOR 回應的是機器人驗證頁,無法自動確認內容。
Blocked to bots
Stone–von Neumann theorem1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q7619449
webhomes.maths.ed.ac.uk/~v1ranick/papers/weil2.pdf
Entry and a PDF by Weil on the theorem.
PDF 可開啟;未逐頁核對它是否為「精確版本」。
Reachable, entry not checked
Chebotarev density theorem1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q1425529Entry only. Compared with ChebotarevDegreeOneIffCheb.lean in the submission.
沒有原始論文連結(貼文以「—」標示)。
Reachable, entry not checked
Hasse norm theorem1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q3527209Entry only. Compared with ExistsNormTensor.lean in the submission.
沒有原始論文連結。
Reachable, entry not checked
Kawamata–Viehweg vanishing1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q6379606Entry only. Compared with KawamataViehweg.lean in the submission.
沒有原始論文連結。
Reachable, entry not checked
Prime number theorem (arithmetic progressions, error term)1000-plus.github.io/thm/Q386292Entry only. Compared with ZerosDisc.lean in the submission.
沒有原始論文連結。
Reachable, entry not checked

5Local reports, data & storyboard files · 本機分析檔

These files exist only in the creator’s working folder. They are listed so the trail is complete, but they have no public URL. Publish them (e.g. in a repository) if viewers should be able to check the numbers.

ItemSourceLocation in the workspaceStatus
Nine-page core theorem dependency report—outputs/rh-theorem-dependencies/riemann-theorem-dependencies.pdf, .texLocal file, not public
Recomputable tables and code—outputs/rh-theorem-dependencies/named-theorem-catalogue.csv, mathlib-mainlines.csv, counts.json, reproduce.zipLocal file, not public
Six-step proof route notes & import audit—work/riemann-proof-route.tex, work/rh-knowledge-audit/imports.json, outputs/rh-knowledge-audit/audit_imports.pyLocal file, not public
Math-knowledge audit report—outputs/rh-knowledge-audit/riemann-math-knowledge-report.pdf, .tex, audit-data.jsonLocal file, not public
Video 4 storyboard & portrait assets—manim_videos/src/v4/video4/ (storyboard_silent_credits.md, fetch_portraits.py, assets/cast.json, assets/portraits_manifest.json, assets/portraits_contact_sheet.png)Local file, not public
Credit evidence table (which theorem each name is credited for)—manim_videos/src/v4/video4/evidence.jsonLocal file, not public

6Portrait credits · 頭貼授權(48 位)

All 48 people shown in the video. 38 have a portrait from Wikimedia Commons; 10 are shown as a plain initials badge because no free, verified portrait was found. The licence on each Commons file page was re-read through the Commons API on 2026-11-21 and matches what is shown. Portraits are cropped to circles; CC BY-SA and GFDL images keep their licence, and the credits here are the attribution.

Portrait of Bernhard Riemann

Bernhard Riemann 1826–1866

Steps 1 & 6 · zeta(s) and its zeros; functional equation
Public domain
Author: Unknown / not stated on Commons
File: Georg Friedrich Bernhard Riemann.jpeg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Peter Gustav Lejeune Dirichlet

Peter Gustav Lejeune Dirichlet 1805–1859

Steps 1 & 6 · characters, L-functions
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Peter Gustav Lejeune Dirichlet.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Hans von Mangoldt

Hans von Mangoldt 1854–1925

Step 1 · weights Lambda(n)
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Hans Karl Friedrich von Mangoldt.jpeg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Leonhard Euler

Leonhard Euler 1707–1783

Steps 1 & 6 · gamma in the centring term; Euler factors
Public domain
Author: Jakob Emanuel Handmann
File: Leonhard Euler.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Pafnuty Chebyshev

Pafnuty Chebyshev 1821–1894

Step 1 · Chebyshev-type inequality
Public domain
Author: Atelier Nadar. Photographe
File: M. Tchebycheef - btv1b53181332k (cropped).jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Arnold Walfisz

Arnold Walfisz 1892–1962

Step 1 · Siegel-Walfisz bound
CC BY 3.0
Author: GFHund
File: Walfisz,Arnold 1920 Göttingen.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Initials badge of Sergei Stepanov

Sergei Stepanov b. 1941

Step 2 · multiplicity idea (borrowed)
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
only candidate is a namesake (Commons 'StepanovSergey.jpg', a different Sergey Stepanov); no verified portrait of the mathematician
No portrait source needed
Portrait of Jean-Benoît Bost

Jean-Benoît Bost b. 1961

Step 2 · lattice slope inequality
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Renate Schmid, Copyright is with MFO
File: Jean-Benoit Bost.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Jørgen Pedersen Gram

Jørgen Pedersen Gram 1850–1916

Step 2 · Gram determinant bound
Public domain
Author: Johannes Hauerslev
File: Jørgen Pedersen Gram by Johannes Hauerslev.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Initials badge of Georges Poitou

Georges Poitou 1926–1989

Step 3 · cohomology window · Poitou-Tate duality
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
no usable free portrait found
No portrait source needed
Portrait of John Tate

John Tate 1925–2019

Step 3 · cohomology window · Poitou-Tate duality
GFDL 1.2
Author: George Bergman
File: John Tate.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Initials badge of Bruce Ferrero

Bruce Ferrero

Step 3 · cohomology window · Ferrero-Washington theorem
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
only candidate was a book cover / unrelated namesake file; no verified portrait
No portrait source needed
Initials badge of Lawrence C. Washington

Lawrence C. Washington b. 1951

Step 3 · cohomology window · Ferrero-Washington theorem
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
no usable free portrait found
No portrait source needed
Initials badge of Kenkichi Iwasawa

Kenkichi Iwasawa 1917–1998

Step 3 · cohomology window · Iwasawa-type cohomology bounds
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
no usable free portrait found
No portrait source needed
Initials badge of Felix Behrend

Felix Behrend 1911–1962

Step 3 · cohomology window · collision-free tower choice
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
only candidate is Kai Behrend (a different mathematician)
No portrait source needed
Portrait of Ichirō Satake

Ichirō Satake 1927–2014

Step 3 · Galois row · Satake parameters
CC BY-SA 4.0
Author: George Bergman
File: Ichiro Satake 2005 (re-scanned).jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Erich Hecke

Erich Hecke 1887–1947

Step 3 · Galois row · Hecke characters
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Konrad Jacobs
File: Erich Hecke.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Ferdinand Georg Frobenius

Ferdinand Georg Frobenius 1849–1917

Steps 3 & 4 · Galois row & ceiling · Frobenius classes
CC BY-SA 3.0
Author: Furfur
File: GeorgFrobenius (cropped).jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Nikolai Chebotaryov

Nikolai Chebotaryov 1894–1947

Step 3 · Galois row · Chebotarev density theorem
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Chebotarev Nikolai Grigoryevich.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Robert Langlands

Robert Langlands b. 1936

Step 3 · Galois row · local Langlands parameters
CC BY-SA 3.0
Author: Author - Dr. Jeff Mozzochi (passed copyright for the photo to owner - professor Robert Phelan Langlands)
File: Langlands2_(cropped).jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Carl Ludwig Siegel

Carl Ludwig Siegel 1896–1981

Step 3 · theta matching · Siegel-Weil formula
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Jacobs, Konrad
File: Carl Ludwig Siegel.jpeg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of André Weil

André Weil 1906–1998

Step 3 · theta matching · Siegel-Weil formula
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Konrad Jacobs
File: André Weil, 1968 (cropped).jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Gotthold Eisenstein

Gotthold Eisenstein 1823–1852

Step 3 · theta matching · Eisenstein series
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Gotthold Eisenstein.jpeg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Initials badge of Yuri Linnik

Yuri Linnik 1915–1972

Step 3 · theta matching · least prime in a progression
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
candidates unclear (family photo / licence not recorded); not verified
No portrait source needed
Initials badge of Marshall Stone

Marshall Stone 1903–1989

Step 3 · theta matching · Stone-von Neumann (local)
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
only a scan of a 1949 letter on Commons, not a portrait
No portrait source needed
Portrait of John von Neumann

John von Neumann 1903–1957

Step 3 · theta matching · Stone-von Neumann (local)
Attribution
Author: Unknown / not stated on Commons
File: JohnvonNeumann-LosAlamos.jpg
Commons only carries a generic “Attribution” tag for this Los Alamos photo; the exact terms are not spelled out.
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Helmut Hasse

Helmut Hasse 1898–1979

Step 3 · theta matching · Hasse norm theorem
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Konrad Jacobs
File: Helmut Hasse.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Heisuke Hironaka

Heisuke Hironaka b. 1931

Step 3 · theta matching · resolution of singularities
CC BY 4.0
Author: 日本学士院
File: Heisuke Hironaka.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Yujiro Kawamata

Yujiro Kawamata b. 1952

Step 3 · theta matching · Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing
CC BY-SA 4.0
Author: Rickinasia
File: Yujiro Kawamata Japanese mathematician.png
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Eckart Viehweg

Eckart Viehweg 1948–2010

Step 3 · theta matching · Kawamata-Viehweg vanishing
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Schmid, Renate
File: Eckart Viehweg.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Alexander Grothendieck

Alexander Grothendieck 1928–2014

Step 3 · theta matching · deformation theory
CC BY-SA 4.0
Author: Konrad Jacobs, Erlangen, Copyright by MFO / Original uploader was AEDP at it.wikipedia
File: Alexander_Grothendieck_-_face.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Initials badge of Suren Arakelov

Suren Arakelov b. 1947

Step 3 · theta matching · Arakelov geometry
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
no usable free portrait found
No portrait source needed
Portrait of Emil Artin

Emil Artin 1898–1962

Foundations · Wedderburn-Artin theorem
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Konrad Jacobs, Erlangen
File: EmilArtin.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Joseph Fourier

Joseph Fourier 1768–1830

Step 4 · finite Fourier orthogonality
Public domain
Author: Julien-Léopold Boilly
File: Fourier2.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Hjalmar Mellin

Hjalmar Mellin 1854–1933

Step 5 · Mellin transform of the ramp
Public domain
Author: Charles Riis
File: Hjalmar Mellin by Charles Riis (Kunstbibliothek Berlin) - crop.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Edmund Landau

Edmund Landau 1877–1938

Step 5 · localized Landau argument
Public domain
Author: Urheber unbekannt
File: Edmund Landau.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Pierre-Simon Laplace

Pierre-Simon Laplace 1749–1827

Step 5 · Laplace transform kernel u^k e^(-sigma u)/k!
Public domain
Author: Jean-Baptiste Paulin Guérin
File: Pierre-Simon, marquis de Laplace (1745-1827) - Guérin.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Henri Lebesgue

Henri Lebesgue 1875–1941

Foundations · dominated convergence
Public domain
Author: Unknown / not stated on Commons
File: Lebesgue 2.jpeg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Guido Fubini

Guido Fubini 1879–1943

Foundations · Fubini's theorem
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Guido Fubini.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Georg Cantor

Georg Cantor 1845–1918

Foundations · Cantor's theorem
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Georg Cantor2.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Andrey Tychonoff

Andrey Tychonoff 1906–1993

Foundations · Tychonoff's theorem
CC BY-SA 2.0 de
Author: Konrad Jacobs, Erlangen
File: Tychonoff.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Eduard Heine

Eduard Heine 1821–1881

Foundations · Heine-Cantor
Public domain
Author: unkwown
File: Heinrich Eduard Heine 1.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Émile Borel

Émile Borel 1871–1956

Foundations · Heine-Borel
Public domain
Author: Agence de presse Mondial Photo-Presse
File: Emile Borel-1932.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Constantin Carathéodory

Constantin Carathéodory 1873–1950

Foundations · Caratheodory (measure)
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Caratheodory constantin.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Initials badge of Abram Besicovitch

Abram Besicovitch 1891–1970

Foundations · Besicovitch covering
Initials badge — no free, verified portrait
Commons candidate has no image URL/licence recorded
No portrait source needed
Portrait of David Hilbert

David Hilbert 1862–1943

Foundations · Hilbert basis theorem
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Hilbert.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Marcel Riesz

Marcel Riesz 1886–1969

Foundations · Riesz extension theorem
Public domain
Author: no coneguts
File: Marcel Riesz.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons
Portrait of Pierre Fatou

Pierre Fatou 1878–1929

Foundations · Fatou-Lebesgue lemma
Public domain
Author: Unknown author
File: Pierre Fatou.jpg
Commons page verified File page on Commons

No portraits match.

7Music · 配樂

The only audio in the video is the theme track.

ItemSourceNotesStatus
Theme track (≈122 BPM) for the hook and credits—Per the project chat: the creator's own track, previously used in the math-history series (so no third-party licence is expected).
No track title, file name or composer is recorded in the project files that were searched. Fill this in before publishing the video description.
Not recorded

8In the earlier pasted list, not in the final cast · 舊名單中、最終名單沒有的人

An earlier draft of the credit list had a different cast (40 people, 29 portraits). These 13 names appeared in it but are not shown in the current 48-person video, because no repository evidence row supports crediting them for this proof. Their Commons files are listed so nothing is lost; do not cite them as part of this video.

NameLicenceCommonsStatus
Hermann MinkowskiPublic domainFile page on CommonsReachable
Stefan BanachPublic domainFile page on CommonsReachable
Atle SelbergCC BY-SA 2.0 deFile page on CommonsReachable
Lars HörmanderCC BY-SA 2.0 deFile page on CommonsReachable
Stephen RallisCC BY-SA 4.0File page on CommonsReachable
Harish-ChandraCC BY 4.0File page on CommonsReachable
Pierre DeligneAttributionFile page on CommonsReachable
Jean-Marc FontaineCC BY-SA 4.0File page on CommonsReachable
Roger HoweCC BY-SA 3.0File page on CommonsReachable
Hervé Jacquetinitials badge (old storyboard)—Local file, not public
James Arthurinitials badge (old storyboard)—Local file, not public
Laurent Clozelinitials badge (old storyboard)—Local file, not public
Sarvadaman Chowlainitials badge (old storyboard)—Local file, not public

Also changed since that draft: Euler and John von Neumann now use different Commons files than the earlier list (both files exist and are listed in section 6).

9Method & known limits · 核對方式與限制

  • Link check: every URL was requested with curl on 2026-11-21 (following redirects). 34 non-portrait URLs: 32 answered 200/206; Princeton University Press answered 403 and JSTOR returned a bot-challenge page (both marked “blocked to bots”). The 38 Commons file pages were checked through the Commons API: all exist and the licence field matches.
  • 1000+ pages are JavaScript pages: the URL answers, but whether Q-number matches the theorem name was not confirmed automatically.
  • Repository move: Deicyde/riemann-hypothesis now redirects to leanprover-community/riemann-hypothesis; the pinned commit link still resolves.
  • Von Neumann: Commons carries only a generic “Attribution” tag (Los Alamos National Laboratory photograph).
  • Missing public links: ICM 2026 committee report (local file only) and the theme track (no title recorded).
  • Not recomputed: all counts in the analysis reports (section 5).